They buy what they want when they want it, and they tell you every year not to bother. Here is what research says actually lands with people like that, and fifteen gifts that are not just more stuff.
Economists have a name for the gap between what a gift cost and what the person receiving it thinks it is worth. In 1993 Joel Waldfogel, then at Yale, asked students to value the gifts they had received over the holidays. On average they put the value at 83.9 percent of what the giver had paid. He called the missing slice "the deadweight loss of Christmas".
The gap is widest for the person who has everything, for a simple reason: anything you could buy them, they could have bought themselves, in the color and size they actually wanted. A gadget, a sweater, a bottle of something good: each competes with their own taste and their own money, and usually loses.
So the gifts that work for this person are the ones they could not have bought: time, attention, experiences, and things that carry a shared memory.
Three findings are worth knowing before you shop.
Experiences tend to beat things. In a 2003 paper in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology titled "To Do or to Have?", Leaf Van Boven and Thomas Gilovich reported that people asked to think about their own purchases said their experiential ones, such as trips, meals and concerts, made them happier than their material ones. Experiences are also harder to compare with what someone already owns.
Experiences bring people closer. Cindy Chan and Cassie Mogilner, in four studies in the Journal of Consumer Research, found that experiential gifts did more to strengthen the relationship between giver and recipient than material gifts, because they are more emotionally evocative. A material gift tied to a shared memory, like a framed photo, did something similar.
Givers underrate sentiment. Julian Givi and Jeff Galak, in the Journal of Consumer Psychology in 2017, found that givers lean toward gifts that match a recipient's stated preferences, while recipients often prefer sentimental gifts more than givers expect. And Amit Kumar and Nicholas Epley, in Psychological Science in 2018, found that people writing letters of gratitude underestimated how pleased the recipients would be.
Put together: for the person who has everything, the safest bets are things to do, things to share and things that say something only you could say.
Experiences and digital gifts can feel thin when there is nothing to unwrap. Print the ticket, the voucher or the first page and put it in a card. Wrap one small physical thing that hints at it: a cookbook for the cooking class, a guidebook for the night away. And write the card properly. For the person who has everything, the card may be the part they keep.
Facts checked on 27 October 2026.
Questions? Write to us. Novellum books are written by AI, for one reader only.